How can we write when our tropes are burning?

[tielan]

Lately overheard in fandom:

OVERTHINKINGIT: Tell me, what do you do with female characters?
FAN 1: Burn them!
OVERTHINKINGIT: And what do you burn apart from women?
FAN 1: More women.
FAN 2: Tropes.
OVERTHINKINGIT: Good, now why are female characters worthless?
FAN 2: Because...they're tropes?
OVERTHINKINGIT: So, how do you tell if a female character is a trope?
FAN 1: She fits into your handy female character flowchart with terms that were totes not stolen from TV tropes.
OVERTHINKINGIT: Ah, but now, can you not also have male characters who are tropes?
FAN 1: Oh...um...yeah, I guess.
OVERTHINKINGIT: Are all tropes bad?
FAN 2: When they apply to female characters!
OVERTHINKINGIT: What else is bad?
FAN 1: Het fic.
FAN 2: People who complain about race representation.
FAN 3: Republicans.
FAN 1: Major characters who aren't white or male and who don't appropriately defer to the white males.
FAN 2: People who write het fic.
FAN 3: Female characters.
OVERTHINKINGIT: Exactly! So, logically...
FAN 2: If she's a female character...then...SHE'S A TROPE!

Dear Overthinking It,

Certainly, you've put together a useful flowchart for identifying tropes. However, not all tropes are bad, and the fact that a character matches a trope does not make them any less "real", "strong", "worthwhile", or "interesting".

You might like to reconsider reducing females - real or fictional - to a single most notable aspect.

not exactly encouraged by your reductionism,
T.

tl;dr version

OVERTHINKINGIT: If your female character fits any trope at all, she's not a "strong female character."
FANDOM: Let's take her out the back and beat the shit out of her!

Comments

[tielan]

Trope are inevitable. I found a hilarious page yesterday which laid out in 8 points why you can't avoid tropes in your story.

I think there was less talk of pitchforking female characters, but it's implicit in the layout of the flowchart: you can be a "strong female character" OR you can be a trope.

FFS, ELLEN RIPLEY was in the tropes section!!

Someone on my other journal pointed out that "it just shows what female protags need to be strong characters and how few of them there are". Actually, what it shows is that women are naturally disadvantaged because the majority of female characters were 'minor cast' in their canon - they don't have the natural immunity or story-assumptions that the white males of their canon do. And then even the ones whose canon is about them (ie. Sailor Moon, Ellen Ripley) get dismissed!

It's a no-win situation.